Critics Choice Awards spark backlash over how one major award was handled

The Critics Choice Awards generated widespread discussion this year, not only because of several unexpected film and television wins, but also due to how one major category was presented during the ceremony, leaving viewers questioning the decision.

While the annual awards are often praised for spotlighting both Hollywood and international talent, this year’s event sparked criticism online after fans noticed that the Best Foreign Language Film award, won by Secret Agent, was not presented on the main stage during the televised ceremony.

It’s ridiculous @CriticsChoice to give the award for Best Foreign Language Film on the Red Carpet, and not on stage as it should be. Even more so considering the excellent quality of films from all over the world represented. Ridiculous and disrespectful. #CriticsChoiceAwards

— Mar.cos (@MAR_cosAL) January 5, 2026

On social media, viewers described the decision as awkward and disappointing, particularly given the growing global reach of international cinema. Some argued that presenting the award off-stage sent the wrong message at a time when non-English language films continue to gain wider recognition and acclaim.

The controversy unfolded alongside a night of results that already had audiences divided. One Battle After Another emerged as one of the evening’s biggest winners, securing Best Picture and Best Director for Paul Thomas Anderson. While critics largely supported the outcome, some viewers had expected Sinners, which led the nominations, to claim the top prize.

Acting categories also prompted mixed reactions. Timothée Chalamet’s Best Actor win for Marty Supreme was praised for its restraint and subtlety, though some fans online felt other performances carried stronger emotional impact. Jessie Buckley’s Best Actress victory for Hamnet similarly split opinion, with audiences debating whether critics favoured nuance over more transformative roles.

Television honours added to the conversation. The Pitt won Best Drama Series and The Studio claimed Best Comedy Series, results that reflected consistent critical backing but did not entirely align with fan-driven buzz surrounding other contenders. Limited series Adolescence dominated its categories, earning praise for its performances while still prompting debate about its overall cultural impact.

The Critics Choice Awards are often viewed as a key indicator of awards-season momentum, but this year’s ceremony highlighted a broader discussion extending beyond winners alone. For many viewers, the way recognition is delivered matters just as much as who receives it, raising fresh questions about representation, visibility and priorities within major awards shows.

Aasiya Niaz